top of page
Harrison Lavelle
Writer
More actions
Profile
Join date: Nov 12, 2025
Posts (3)
Sep 20, 2026 ∙ 5 min
Tracing Copyright Law from Photo to Pore – Part II: Why the En Banc Ninth Circuit Should Preserve the Substantial Similarity Test
[1] A Note from the Author I previously wrote a detailed review of the Ninth Circuit’s precedent-based rejection of photographer Jeffrey Sedlik’s appeal of an unfavorable jury verdict in a copyright infringement case. At the time, I examined Judge Wardlaw’s and Judge Johnstone’s passionate arguments urging the Ninth Circuit to grant rehearing en banc and abandon its intrinsic-extrinsic test for evaluating whether protected works and allegedly infringing works are substantially similar for...
47
0
Apr 5, 2026 ∙ 6 min
Tracing Copyright Law from Photo to Pore: The Fate of the Ninth Circuit’s Controversial Substantial Similarity Test
[1] Introduction A battle is brewing in the Ninth Circuit over what test courts should use to determine whether allegedly infringing works are “substantially similar” to their copyright-protected counterparts. While the three-judge panel rejected photographer Jeffrey Sedlik’s appeal based on binding precedent, two judges wrote separately calling for the Circuit to go in a different direction. If the Ninth Circuit grants rehearing en banc and abandons its current test, creators of...
56
0
Nov 12, 2025 ∙ 6 min
Totes & Trademarks: Inside the Ongoing Battle Between Trader Joe’s and Its Union
[1] Overview On September 8, 2025, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit revived a trademark infringement lawsuit brought by Trader Joe’s Company (“Trader Joe’s”) against Trader Joe’s United (“TJU”)—the grocery store chain’s employee union.[2] The decision is the latest installment in an ongoing battle over products sold by TJU which allegedly infringe Trader Joe’s federally registered trademarks.[3] The dispute raises important issues at the juncture of...
145
0
bottom of page